Health Insurance After Divorce in Massachusetts
If you are getting divorced in Massachusetts, you probably have an urgent question: “Can I stay on my spouse’s health insurance after the divorce” — or “Can my spouse stay on mine?
For many people the answer is yes. If the covered spouse works for a Massachusetts state, county, or municipal government, the ex-spouse can stay on the plan.
The answer is usually yes, too, when the coverage comes through a smaller employer — as a rough rule of thumb, a company with fewer than about 50 employees — because small employers almost always buy the kind of plan that Massachusetts law protects.
The answer is usually no, however, when the coverage comes from a large company, because most big employers run a type of plan that federal law exempts from MA laws protecting health insurance for ex-spouses. Even then there are exceptions: a handful of large employers — including Harvard, MIT, and Boston University — cover ex-spouses anyway. Because company size is only a rule of thumb, the single most useful step is to call the HR or benefits office of the employer whose plan covers you and ask one plain-English question:
“Can my spouse stay on my health insurance after my divorce if there is a Court Order to keep them on it?”
How they answer tells you which of the categories below applies to you. The stakes are high: a national study in the Journal of Health and Social Behavior found that roughly 115,000 American women lose private health insurance in the months following divorce each year — about 65,000 of them becoming completely uninsured — and that “women’s rates of insurance coverage remain depressed for more than two years after divorce.”1
Government Workers: The Clearest Case
If your spouse works for a Massachusetts state, county, or municipal government, the ex-spouse’s right to remain on the plan is guaranteed by statute: G.L. c. 32A, § 11A for state employees and G.L. c. 32B, § 9H for county and municipal employees.5 Because these are public plans, the federal preemption that can defeat coverage at a private company does not apply here, so this is the most dependable “yes” of all.
Smaller Employers: Usually Covered Under Massachusetts Law
Most smaller Massachusetts companies — as a rule of thumb, those with fewer than about 50 employees — buy their coverage from an insurance company or HMO. Plans bought this way are called “fully insured,” and they must follow Massachusetts insurance law. A group of state statutes requires the insurer to keep your former spouse eligible for coverage after the divorce “as if said judgment had not been entered.”3 These laws cover commercial insurers (G.L. c. 175, § 110I), Blue Cross and Blue Shield plans (G.L. c. 176A, § 8F; c. 176B, § 6B), HMOs (G.L. c. 176G, § 5A), and preferred provider plans (G.L. c. 176I, § 9).3 Eligibility continues as long as the employee stays in the group plan, and — importantly — “as long as the insured spouse has not remarried, the insurer may not charge an additional premium for the family coverage.”3
This protection is unusual in the US, and it can result in large savings in premiums over time. In most states, divorce simply ends a spouse’s eligibility and COBRA is the only fallback; Massachusetts is one of a small number of states that require an insured plan to keep covering an ex-spouse after divorce.4
Larger Employers: Usually “Self-Insured,” and Usually No Coverage for Ex-Spouses
Large companies typically do not buy insurance at all. Instead they pay their employees’ medical claims out of their own funds and hire an insurance company only to administer the plan. These “self-insured” plans are the reason your insurance card tells you nothing — a familiar carrier’s name can sit on top of either kind of plan. The distinction is decisive, because federal law “exempts self-insured employer group health plans from state insurance laws, including the Massachusetts laws that extend health insurance eligibility to a divorced spouse.”2 And it is the common case: by many estimates, roughly three-quarters of Massachusetts workers are in self-insured plans, especially at larger employers.
So if the coverage comes through a big employer, the plan is probably not required to keep your ex-spouse — but “not required” is not the same as “never.” Some large self-insured employers — including Harvard, MIT, and Boston University — voluntarily allow an ex-spouse to remain on the plan, often when a divorce judgment provides for it. That is precisely why the HR phone call matters: a plan’s own policy is the only way to know. If your plan will not continue coverage, your main options are:
- COBRA. Private employers with 20 or more employees must offer a divorced spouse up to 36 months of continuation coverage, at up to 102% of the premium. Divorce is a “qualifying event,” but you must notify the plan administrator within 60 days of the final judgment or you lose the right.6
- Mini-COBRA. For small employers with 2–19 employees, a Massachusetts law (G.L. c. 176J, § 9) provides similar continuation rights.6
- The Massachusetts Health Connector. Any resident without access to affordable group coverage can buy an individual plan.
How Remarriage Can Change Everything
The effects of remarriage on your health insurance depend on which spouse remarries and whether you are relying on state law or COBRA.
Under Massachusetts insurance law (“fully-insured” plans and MA state/county/municipal employees): If the covered ex-spouse remarries, the right to stay on the plan ends. If instead the employee (plan participant) remarries, the ex-spouse may still continue coverage — but possibly through a separate “rider” or individual policy, and the insurer is then allowed to charge an added premium. As the Bar Association review explains, “the coverage ends when the dependent spouse remarries, but the judgment may provide for coverage to continue after the insured spouse remarries.”3 Because of this, your separation agreement should spell out what happens if either person remarries.
Under COBRA: The rule is simpler — “remarriage of either party does not affect continuation rights during the 36-month COBRA period,” and the plan cannot add a premium because of a remarriage.6
Who Pays? Put the Cost in the Separation Agreement
Even when an insurer cannot raise the total premium, ERISA lets the employer stop contributing toward the ex-spouse’s share — so the family may have to pay more than before the divorce to keep the same coverage. Vague language such as covering a spouse “as long as there is no extra cost” “does not adequately address the allocation of costs.”7 A well-drafted separation agreement states exactly who pays the premium or the marginal cost of maintaining coverage, and what happens when COBRA runs out — a point the Probate and Family Court can incorporate into your divorce judgment.7
The Right Separation Agreement Language, and How It Becomes a Court Order
An insurer or HR office will not take your word for it that they must continue to cover your ex-spouse. They will want to see the obligation written into your divorce judgment. Your separation agreement should therefore state expressly that the employee spouse will keep the other spouse on the group health plan (and any successor plan) for as long as the plan and Massachusetts law allow. It should also say whether coverage continues after the employee spouse remarries, because under Massachusetts law it continues only if the judgment provides for it. As the Attorney General’s guide advises, “You can write language in a separation agreement or proposed judgment requiring your spouse to continue health coverage for you after the divorce. You must have this language approved by the judge.”8 When you file the agreement with the Probate and Family Court, the judge reviews it. If the judge finds it fair and reasonable, the judge approves it and incorporates it into the Judgment of Divorce.8 At that point the promise is no longer just a contract between spouses. It is a court order, enforceable through a contempt action, and a certified copy of the judgment is the document you send to the plan administrator. If COBRA may be needed, send it within 60 days.
Get Guidance From a Mediator Who Knows the Rules
Health insurance is exactly the kind of technical, high-stakes issue where a knowledgeable neutral saves you money and stress. Through divorce mediation, you can work through the self-insured question, the remarriage rules, and the cost allocation together — without a courtroom fight. Attorney Rueschemeyer, a magna cum laude Ivy League graduate, is comfortable with exactly these technical and financial details, and explains them so both spouses understand their options and reach an agreement that works for both of them.
If you are facing a complex or high-asset divorce in Massachusetts, contact Attorney Rueschemeyer to make sure your health coverage — and your financial future — is protected.
Blog post by Benjamin Bailey, PhD
Endnotes
- Bridget K. Lavelle & Pamela J. Smock, Divorce and Women’s Risk of Health Insurance Loss, 53 Journal of Health and Social Behavior 413 (2012). The study estimates that approximately 115,000 women lose private health insurance annually in the months surrounding divorce, roughly 65,000 of whom become uninsured, and finds that “women’s rates of insurance coverage remain depressed for more than two years after divorce.” ↩
- Clare D. McGorrian, A Spouse’s Right to Health Insurance After Divorce: A Review, Massachusetts Bar Association Section Review, Vol. 5, No. 2. ERISA’s preemption clause, 29 U.S.C. § 1144(b)(2)(B), “exempts self-insured employer group health plans from state insurance laws, including the Massachusetts laws that extend health insurance eligibility to a divorced spouse.” See Bergin v. Wausau Ins. Co., 863 F. Supp. 34 (D. Mass. 1994); Cellilli v. Cellilli, 939 F. Supp. 72 (D. Mass. 1996). ↩
- G.L. c. 175, § 110I (commercial carriers); G.L. c. 176A, § 8F and c. 176B, § 6B (Blue Cross/Blue Shield); G.L. c. 176G, § 5A (HMOs); G.L. c. 176I, § 9 (preferred provider arrangements). A member who is party to a judgment of divorce “shall be and remain eligible” for coverage “as if said judgment had not been entered,” and “as long as the insured spouse has not remarried, the insurer may not charge an additional premium for the family coverage.” McGorrian, supra note 2 (quoting G.L. c. 175, § 110I(a)–(b)). ↩
- Unlike Massachusetts, most states do not require an insured group plan to continue covering a former spouse after divorce; in those states a divorced spouse’s eligibility ends with the marriage and federal COBRA continuation is the primary option. The Massachusetts continuation statutes cited in note 3 are therefore distinctive among the states. ↩
- G.L. c. 32A, § 11A (Massachusetts state employees); G.L. c. 32B, § 9H (county and municipal employees). McGorrian, supra note 2 (“State, county and municipal government employees in Massachusetts enjoy the same protections.”). ↩
- Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA), 29 U.S.C. § 1161 et seq.; divorce and legal separation are “qualifying events” (29 U.S.C. § 1163) entitling a qualified beneficiary to up to 36 months of coverage (29 U.S.C. § 1167), at up to 102% of premium, with 60-day notice to the plan administrator required. Massachusetts “mini-COBRA,” G.L. c. 176J, § 9, extends similar rights to employers with 2–19 employees. “Under COBRA, remarriage of either party does not affect continuation rights during the 36-month COBRA period.” McGorrian, supra note 2. ↩
- McGorrian, supra note 2. Divorce-judgment language requiring coverage “as long as there is no extra cost” “does not adequately address the allocation of costs,” because although the insurer cannot increase the total premium, “the parties may have to contribute more toward the cost of the family plan than before the divorce.” The Probate and Family Court’s authority to allocate coverage and cost derives from G.L. c. 208, §§ 17, 34 and G.L. c. 209, § 32; see also Supp. Prob. Court Rule 411. ↩
- Office of the Attorney General & Health Law Advocates, Staying Healthy: A Guide to Keeping Health Insurance After Divorce 2, 5 (Nov. 2002) (“You can write language in a separation agreement or proposed judgment requiring your spouse to continue health coverage for you after the divorce. You must have this language approved by the judge.”; “You can stay on your ex-spouse’s group plan after he or she remarries, as long as your divorce judgment provides for it.”). On court approval and incorporation of a separation agreement into the judgment, see G.L. c. 208, § 1A. ↩